IntroductionHome Gyms have several benefits over the commercial gymnasiums. especially in these times of pandemic where you should avoid contacts. The market of the Home Gyms has been dominated by the “Total Gym” family for over two decades. But recently Bowflex, GR8Flex and Vigorfit have emerged has strong alternatives to the Total Gym. In this comparison we will be comparing the most expensive of the Total Gym model, the XLS with the Vigorfit and GR8FLEX . Let’s admit it, “Total Gym is expensive. There was a demand for a less expensive home gym models that could offer the same features and yet be affordable, thus the Vigorfit and the GR8FLEX were born.
Total Gym XLS
Compare Types of Exercises: Total Gym XLS vs Vigorfit vs GR8Flex
All the three home gyms [Total Gym XLS, GR8FLEX and the VigorFit] offer the same exercise routines, these include:
- Strength Training – This is the most important of the exercises when you have to develop STRENGTH. Traditionally strength training is done through free weights. But these home gyms let you do strength training using your own body weight and resistance bands. Total Gym XLS uses your own body-weight while the GR8FLEX and VigorFit use combination of body weight and resistance bands.GR8FLEX and Vigorfit offer better strength training then Total Gym XLS, owing to their improved resistance.
- Pilates Training – It is a low-impact exercising technique that improves flexibility and posture and also develops muscles. All the three gyms are at par in Pilates training.
- Abdominal Training – Core training is one of the most important feature of any home gym. And so do Total Gym XLS, Vigorfit and GR8FLEX come with the requisite attachments. Total GYM XLS comes with the “Ab Cruch” attachment, the GR8FLEX comes with the “Crunch AB” accessory and the Vigorfit comes with “AB & BUN Trainer”. The mechanism of these attachments is exactly the same.
Compare Price: Total Gym XLS vs Vigorfit vs GR8FlexPriced at $1300 Total Gym XLS is the most expensive of the three home gyms. Vigorfit is priced at $399, 225% cheaper than the Total Gym XLS and 142% cheaper than the GR8FLEX. The GR8FLEX is 25% cheaper than the Total Gym XLS.
The PRICE is the focal point of this comparison and the main selling point of the Vigorfit and GR8FLEX home gyms. The Vigorfit is the clear winner here but then there are various other factors that can influence your buying decisions.
Compare Number of Exercises: Total Gym XLS vs Vigorfit vs GR8Flex
- Total Gym XLS lets you do over 80 exercises.
- Vigorfit claims to offer more than 107 exerciser
- GR8FLEX Gym claims to offer over 100 exercises.
Compare ResistanceHer is where the GR8FLEX and Vigorfit differ with the Total Gym XLS. The Total Gym XLS offers only body-weight resistance while Vigorfit and GR8FLEX combine resistance bands training with body weight resistance.
Total Gym XLS – Offers 6 levels of resistance. As you increase the incline angle the resistance increases too. But the resistance offered by Total Gym XLS is not enough. Many user reviews have reported that they ran out of resistance with the Total Gym XLS, and this resistance issue is addressed by Vigorfit and GR8FLEX.
Vigorfit – Offers 15 levels of inclined resistance combined with 188 lbs. of resistance with power bands on pulleys. On top of this you can use 100 lbs. of free weights for independent exercises. You can add up to 5 resistance bands.
GR8FLEX – It too offers 15 levels of inclined body weight resistance plus 50 lbs. of extra resistance thanks to the bands. You can add up to 4 resistance bands.
Verdict – Resistance help build stronger muscles and this is one area where home gyms often lack when compared with commercial gyms. Both Vigorfit and GR8FLEX have resistance bands but Vigorfit offers more resistance compared to GR8FLEX. The Vigorfit offers the greatest resistance of all the three home gyms. This makes Vigorfit a truly versatile home gym that offers the requisite resistance for beginners as well as experts.
Compare Accessories: Total Gym XLS vs Vigorfit vs GR8FLEX
Compare Pilates KitsPilates exercise are great for strengthening and elongating muscles and promote weight loss too.
- Total Gym XLS – Total Gym Pilates kit consists of Pilates Toe Bar, Leg Pull Accessory, 24” Leg extension rope and 2 Ankle cuffs and DVD.
- Vigorfit – The Vigorfit Pilates kit consists of Dual Leg Rope System, Heavy duty comfortably cushioned shoulder pad lock and Toe bar.
- GR8FLEX – Does come with Leg Harness/Pulley System that can be used for Pilates exercises.
- Verdict – All the three home gyms come with this accessory. The Vigorfit manufacturers call it a “DUAL LEG ROPE SYSTEM” while GR8FLEX and Total Gym XLS promoters call it simply “Leg Pull” accessory. Total Gym XLS and Vigorfit gyms have the complete Pilates kits. But Toal Gym XLS has a slight edge over the Vigorfit. GR8FLEX has no Pilates kit.
Compare Abdominal Training Accessories
- Total Gym XLS – Its called the “Ab Crunch” attachment. It consists of two cushioned supports that attaches to the rails of the Total Gym XLS. The XLS.
- Vigorfit – Comes with the AB & BUN TRAINER a.k.a “ABT” attachment. It is a square padded board and works pretty much the same as the Ab Crunch works on the Total Gym XLS.
- GR8FLEX – It is called the “Crunch Ab Accessory”. It consists of a racing bike handle that you hold to get a firm grip. The arm resits are padded.
- Verdict – All the gyms have the abdominal exercise attachment that pretty much works on the same principles. But the one that comes with the GR8FLEX is much helpful as you can hold the handles while exercising.
Compare Squat Stand
Inclined squats are a great way to tone and strengthen your leg and thigh muscles. All the three home gyms in question let you do the inclined squats – thanks to the squat stand/board attachment that you can attach at the lower end of the glide board. The difference is – Total Gym XLS has an oval squat board while the GR8FLEX and Vigorfit have square boards. Also GR8FLEX has the biggest squat board of the three gyms. The problem though is that these squats are not as effective as the standing ones.
Compare Wing Attachments
The Total Gym XLS and GR8FLEX come with the “Wing” attachment. The wing attachment is basically a padded bar that runs across the frame of the gym and is to be attached at the top end or lower end of the glide-rail.
The Vigorfit on the other hand comes with a Pull up bar at the top end and a push-up bar at the lower end. Both these bars are removable and serve the same purpose as the Wing attachments. The Pull-up bar can be used to do sit-ups. The down side of the absence of padded armrest in Vigorfit is that you cannot do the ab crunches.
The Wing attachment targets muscles in the back, shoulders, legs and abdomen and is used for pulling and pushing exercises. When the Wing attachment is connected at the top of the glide rail, it is used to pull the body weight building stronger arms and chest. When connected to the lower end of the glide-rail, it is used to perform leg exercises and squats.
Verdict – GR8FLEX with its handled and cushioned Wing Attachment offers better grip while doing the kneeling ab crunches.
Total GYM XLS vs Vigorfit vs GR8FLEX: Tabular Comparison
|Total Gym XLS||Vigorfit||GR8FLEX|
|Compare Resistance||6 levels inclined resistance. No resistance bands.||15 levels of inclined resistance combined with up to 5 resistance bands.||15 levels of inclined resistance with 50 lbs. of additional resistance through bands.|
|Does it come with a Push-Up Bar?||No||Yes||No|
|Does it come with a Pull-Up Bar?||No||Yes||No|
|Does it include a Wing Attachment?||Yes||No||Yes|
|Does it come with a Abdominal Exercise Attachment?||Yes [Ab Crunch Accessory]||Yes [Ab & Bun Trainer]||Yes [Crunch Ab Accessory]|
|Does it come with a Heavy Duty Weight Bar?||No||Yes||No|
|Does it come with a Leg Rope System?||Yes||Yes||Yes|
|Does it include Pilates Shoulder Pads?||No||Yes||No|
|Does it come with a Sit Up Station?||No||Yes||No|
|Does it come with a Toe Bar?||No||Yes||No|
|Does it include a Squat Board?||Yes||Yes||Yes|
|Compare Warranty||Lifetime Warranty on Frame, 6-Month Warranty on Parts||Bumper to Bumper Lifetime Warranty||Lifetime Warranty on Gym and Parts|
|Compare Max User Weight Supported||400 lbs.||440 lbs.||450 lbs.|
|Compare Number of Bands||No bands||5 bands||4 bands|
|Does it include a EZ Curl Bar?||No||No||Yes|
Vigorfit vs GR8FLEX
- Vigorfit and GR8FLEX are quiet identical
- They offer the same resistance levels, but differ in the number of exercises you can do with them.
- GR8FLEX offers more exercises than the Vigorfit.
- GR8FLEX comes in 8 models while Vigorfit has only one.
- Vigorfit has more Pilates accessories than the GR8FLEX.
- The most important accessory that Vigorfit has is the heavy-duty weight bar.
- Vigorfit comes with a Push-up and Pullup bar which the GR8FLEX lacks.
- GR8FLEX comes with Wing Atatchments which the Vigorfit lacks.
- GR8FLEX includes an EZ Curl Bar which the Vigorfit lacks. EZ Curl Bar that let’s you do the Shoulder raises, Tricep extensions, and Skull crushers.
Vigorfit vs Total Gym XLS
- Vigorfit clearly has many more features that the Total Gym XLS.
- Vigorfit offers 107 exercises while Total Gym XLS offers 80.
- Vigorfit comes with Push-up and Pull-up bars which the Total Gym XLS lacks.
- Total Gym XLS comes with a Wing Attachment which the Vigorfit lacks.
- Total Gym XLS lacks the heavy-weight bar that Vigorfit comes with.
- Vigorfit helps you get the 6-pack-abs thanks to the Sit-ip station .
- Vigor fit offers more resistance than the Total Gym XLS. Many users complaint about the inadequate resistance of the Total Gym XLS.
GR8FLEX vs Total Gym XLS
- GR8FLEX offers 75% more exercises than the Total Gym XLS.
- Total Gym XLS does not have resistance bands while the GR8FLEX does have, offering more resistance to hardenened exercise doers.
- The EZ Curl Bar is another advnatge that GR8FLEX has over the Total Gym XLS.
- Apart from these parameters, GR8FLEX and Total Gym XLS are pretty simlar.
Vigorfit is an reaction to the Total Gym Vigorfit accommodates users up to 6.5 inch tall. Total Gym XLS vs GR8FLEX Vigorfit Vs Total Gym XLS Compare Guarantee and Warranty Where does Total Gym XLS score over Vigorfit and GR8FLEX Where does Vigorfit score over Total Gym XLS and GR8FLEX Where does GR8FLEX score over Total Gym XLS and Vigorfit